
It's Not Your Fault. But What Happens Next Is. | Solo Episode
- David Shaft

- Jul 13, 2023
- 4 min read
Updated: Apr 6
You didn't choose where you started. You didn't choose your family, your neighborhood, your economic situation, the injuries that happened, or the doors that closed before you were old enough to know they were open. None of that is your fault. But the rest of your life? That part is entirely on you. And the sooner you accept that, the faster your communication, your leadership, and your career start to move.
This episode comes from a very personal place. I want to talk about a knee injury that took away the athletic path I was on and what happened in the months after that, when someone told me to join the debate team and I had absolutely no idea that advice would change my life.
The Injury and What It Took With It
I was an athlete. That was part of my identity. When the knee went, it didn't just take away a sport. It took away a future I had been building toward, a community, a reason to show up every day with a clear purpose. That kind of loss is disorienting in a way that's hard to explain if you haven't lived it.
I want to be honest about the fact that I sat in that loss for a while. I wasn't immediately motivated or positive or grateful for the redirect. I was frustrated. And then somebody, almost casually, said something that changed the entire trajectory of what came next.
They told me to join the debate team.
Why That Advice Landed the Way It Did
I didn't take that advice immediately. It sat with me. Because at the time, standing up in front of people and making arguments felt completely foreign compared to what I had been doing with my body and my effort every day in practice. But eventually I showed up. And something clicked.
Debate taught me how to construct an argument under pressure. How to read the other side and anticipate their position. How to communicate clearly and fast when the clock is running and you don't have time to be sloppy. How to make your point land when the other person is actively looking for the holes in it.
Those are communication skills that I use every single day as a banking director who leads 40 people. And I never would have found them if the first door hadn't closed hard.
The Lesson Nobody Wants to Hear
Here's the thing about "it's not your fault." It's true. And it's also not a strategy. You can acknowledge every unfair thing that happened to you and still be completely stuck. The acknowledgment doesn't move you forward. The decision does.
The decision is: given where I am right now, with what I actually have, what am I going to do next? Not what I wish I had. Not what I should have had. What I have. That's the starting point. And it's the only starting point that leads anywhere.
Most people spend years waiting for fair. Waiting for the situation to become what it should have been. And the situation doesn't change, because fair is not a thing that happens to you. It's a thing you build, slowly, with whatever you've got, starting from wherever you actually are.
What Communication Has to Do With All of This
I talk about this on a communication podcast because the shift I'm describing, from what happened to me to what I'm going to do about it, that shift lives in language. It lives in how you talk to yourself and how you talk about your situation to other people.
People who stay stuck in what happened to them communicate that story in a way that makes it permanent. It becomes their identity. It becomes the explanation for every current limitation. And the people around them start to hear it that way too.
People who move forward communicate differently. They acknowledge the reality without making it the center of the story. They shift the language from "this happened to me" to "this is what I did with it." That shift is not denial. It's agency. And agency is the foundation of every leadership skill I've seen in 20 years of working with people who build things.
The debate team didn't fix the knee. But it gave me a voice. And the voice turned out to be more valuable than anything I had been building before the injury.
Key Takeaways from This Episode
Your starting conditions are not your fault. What you do with the rest is completely on you.
Debate taught David communication under pressure, a skill that transferred directly to leading teams in banking.
Acknowledging hardship is necessary. Making it permanent and central to your identity is a choice, and it's the wrong one.
The language shift from "this happened to me" to "this is what I did with it" is where leadership and agency begin.
Closed doors often redirect you to skills and paths you never would have found otherwise.
Related Episodes
Episode 5 covers failure as a feedback loop and makes the case that the attempts that don't work are the ones that build the most skill. Episode 1 shares the car accident story and what forced stillness revealed about communication and purpose.
Watch and Listen to the Full Episode
Level Up Your Communication Skills
If this conversation resonated with you, download The Communication Playbook, a free guide to the frameworks and strategies guests on Conversations That Count use to communicate, lead, and win.
Get your free copy: https://conversations-that-count.kit.com/e7fa86a708
FLAG: NO TRANSCRIPT. Blog post generated from metadata only. Paste transcript to generate full version.



Comments